Weak Car Cranking with Clicking Sounds? It Might Not Be the Battery!

The failure of the car starter motor's solenoid (commonly known as the ''solenoid switch'' or ''electromagnetic pull-in switch'') is a very common issue. Although it's a small component, once it fails, the car cannot start.

Below is a detailed explanation of the other symptoms, main causes, and handling methods when the solenoid fails.

I. Other Symptoms of Solenoid Failure

Besides the most direct symptom of ''no response when turning the key,'' the solenoid can also exhibit the following symptoms under varying degrees of failure:

1️⃣ Single ''Click'' Sound, Then Starter Doesn't Turn

✅ This is the most typical symptom. When you turn the key to the start position, you only hear a clear ''click'' from the engine bay (this is the sound of the solenoid's internal coil engaging and the drive gear being pushed out to hit the stop ring), but the starter motor itself does not rotate.

✅ Cause: The main contacts (high-current contacts) of the solenoid are burnt, oxidized, or have poor contact, preventing the high current from the battery from reaching the starter motor. Therefore, the motor gets no power. However, the hold-in coil and pull-in coil can still work normally, allowing the ''engagement'' action to complete.

2️⃣ Weak Cranking with ''Clicking'' Sounds

✅ Manifestation: The starter motor turns very slowly and weakly, unable to crank the engine, and may be accompanied by a continuous ''clicking'' or grinding sound.

✅ Cause: Poor contact at the solenoid's main contacts results in excessive resistance, severely reducing the voltage and current reaching the motor. Simultaneously, because the engagement is incomplete, the drive gear cannot fully mesh with the engine flywheel ring gear, causing the grinding sound.

3️⃣ Starter Spins Freely (Freewheeling)

✅ Manifestation: When turning the key, you can hear the starter motor spinning at high speed (''whirring—''), but the engine crankshaft does not turn.

✅ Cause: The internal shift fork mechanism of the solenoid is stuck, detached, or the drive gear is severely worn. Although the solenoid coil is energized, the shift fork cannot push the drive gear out to engage with the flywheel, causing the motor to spin freely.

4️⃣ Starter Doesn't Stop After Releasing Key

✅ Manifestation: After the engine successfully starts and you release the key, the starter continues to operate, producing a frightening grinding roar.

✅ Cause: The solenoid's core sleeve or contacts are welded together, preventing it from powering off and retracting. This is a very dangerous fault that can quickly burn out the starter. The power supply must be cut off immediately (e.g., by disconnecting the battery negative terminal).

5️⃣ Intermittent Fault

✅ Manifestation: Sometimes it starts on the first try, other times it requires several turns of the key to get a response.
✅ Cause: This is usually a precursor to the complete failure of the internal contacts or coils within the solenoid, indicating unstable contact.

II. Main Causes

Solenoid failure is usually not due to a single cause. Common reasons include:

1️⃣ Contact Burning and Oxidation
✅ The primary cause. The solenoid contacts instantly承受 hundreds of amps of current when engaged, generating a massive arc. After long-term use, the contact surfaces become burnt and oxidized, increasing contact resistance and preventing effective current flow.

2️⃣ Coil Burnout
✅ The pull-in coil or hold-in coil burns out and opens due to prolonged energization (e.g., multiple starting attempts, difficult starting), overvoltage, or manufacturing defects. Once a coil burns out, the solenoid completely loses its magnetic force and cannot actuate.

3️⃣ Mechanical Jamming
✅ The internal plunger (movable iron core) or shift fork mechanism becomes stuck due to oil sludge, corrosion, or wear, preventing normal movement.

4️⃣ Return Spring Failure
✅ The spring responsible for pulling the drive gear back becomes fatigued or breaks, causing the gear to fail to disengage from the flywheel after power is cut.

5️⃣ External Connection Issues
✅ Loose or oxidized power terminals on the solenoid (especially the thick cable from the battery) cause poor contact, which can also trigger similar symptoms.

III. Handling Methods and Diagnostic Steps

Important Note: Before any operation, ensure the vehicle is in Park (or with parking brake firmly engaged), and disconnect the battery negative terminal to prevent accidents.

‼️ Diagnostic Steps:

1️⃣ Preliminary Check

✅ Turn on the headlights and try to start the car. If the headlights dim significantly or go out, it indicates the solenoid has engaged and is drawing current, but the starter isn't turning. The problem likely lies with the main contacts or the starter itself.
✅ If the headlight brightness remains unchanged and you only hear a ''click,'' it can basically be confirmed as a problem with the solenoid or the starter circuit.

2️⃣ Direct Test Method (Requires an assistant and basic tools)

✅ Short-circuit Test: Carefully use a thick screwdriver or wrench to short-circuit the two largest terminals on the solenoid simultaneously (one is the input from the battery, the other is the output to the starter motor).
✅ If the starter immediately spins at high speed: It means the starter motor itself is good, and the fault is 100% in the solenoid.
✅ If the starter still doesn't turn or turns weakly: It indicates a problem with the starter motor itself (e.g., worn brushes, armature fault) or the wiring.
✅ Warning: This operation will produce strong sparks. Ensure the vehicle is in Neutral, and the tool does not touch any other metal parts to prevent short circuits.

3️⃣ Voltage Measurement Method (Using a Multimeter)

✅ Measure the control wire (usually a thin wire) of the solenoid's pull-in coil to see if there is 12V during starting. If there is voltage but the solenoid doesn't actuate, then the solenoid is faulty.
✅ During starting, measure the voltage at the output terminal leading to the starter motor. If the input terminal has 12V but the output terminal voltage is far below 10V, it indicates poor contact at the main contacts.

‼️ Handling Methods:

1️⃣ Replace the Entire Assembly (Most Recommended)
✅ For modern cars, the safest and most reliable method is to directly replace the entire starter assembly. Because the solenoid and starter are usually designed and matched as an integrated unit. Replacing just the solenoid might lead to problems with the old starter soon after.

2️⃣ Replace Only the Solenoid (Economical Option)
✅ If it's confirmed that only the solenoid is damaged, and a completely matching model can be found, it can be replaced separately. This requires removing the starter from the vehicle and then disassembling it for replacement.

3️⃣ Repair/Clean Contacts (Only applicable to serviceable models)
✅ For some older vehicle model solenoids, the housing can be opened, and the burnt contacts can be lightly sanded with sandpaper or a file to restore flatness. However, this is usually a temporary solution, as the metal layer of the burnt contacts has thinned and will likely fail again soon.

‼️ Summary & Recommendations:

When the above symptoms appear, first use the ''short-circuit test'' for a preliminary diagnosis of the fault point. Considering the critical importance of the starting system for vehicle safety, unless you have extensive automotive repair experience, it is recommended to send the vehicle to a professional repair shop for inspection and replacement. Technicians will use professional equipment for diagnosis and provide you with the most suitable repair solution.

====================

💻 💻

Discover More:

https://www.spartlink.com.my

https://www.facebook.com/SPARTLINKENT.SB

📲 📲

WhatsApp: https://wa.me/60122187488

🛒🛒

Shopee: https://www.shopee.com.my/spartlink

Lazada: https://www.lazada.com.my/shop/spartlink

📌 Address ：

Google Map: https://osini.co/SPARTLINK

or

Waze: https://osini.co/SPARTLINKENT_SB